Table of Contents
A little about Perch and Bass
Both perch and bass are popular fish for fishing and eating. This guide goes over the the similarities and differences between the two species. Our comparison will include visual, habitat, food value, taste, and texture-based data.
What is a Perch?
Perch or Perca fluviatilis is an aggressively carnivorous fish. They occupy ponds, lakes, and rivers in North America. During spring, female perch lay strings of eggs in the shallow water. When fully grown, a perch can weigh up to 3 kg (or around 7 lbs).
What is a Bass?
Bass refers to an extensive range of fishes. Micropterus salmoides or the largemouth bass is one of the most well-known species. It is a predatory freshwater fish sharing the habitat with perch. Usually, bass spawn in late April and grows up to be about 5.5 kg in weight (or around 12 lbs).
The similarities and differences between perch & bass.
What are the similarities between perch & bass?
- The white perch and the white bass are visually similar
- Bass is a species that is closely related to the perch
- Both largemouth bass and perch are freshwater species
- Great sources of protein, calcium, and Vitamin B12
What are the differences between perch vs. bass?
- The white bass has faint stripes and is larger than the white perch
- Perch has fewer types compared to bass
- Bass tastes fishy, while perch boasts a sweet taste
- The bass has a firm texture, but the perch flesh is soft
Similarities between perch and bass expanded.
Visual similarities.
It is easy to confuse white perch with white bass. However, except for a few key differences, they look similar. The white perch, in reality, is a temperate bass. Nevertheless, they share a close resemblance in shape, fins, and tail.
Etymological similarities.
The origin of the word Bass is the Middle English Bars. It means ‘perch’. Bass belongs to the order of Perciformes. Simply put, Perciformes refers to fishes that are like the perch.
Similarities of habitat
Perch inhabits the freshwater ponds, rivers, and lakes of North America. They share the ecosystem with basses. Both perch and basses also have carnivorous food habits.
Nutritional similarities
Bass and perch are among the protein-rich food. The amount of protein they provide is also close. Perch has 11.6g protein per fillet, while the bass has 14.9g per fillet. Besides the protein, the two fish species are also good sources of calcium and Vitamin B12.
The differences between perch and bass
Visual similarities
Bass is more prominent compared to perch. The freshwater white bass is about 10-12” long. On the other hand, the white perch is only 5-7” long.
On the body of the white bass, there are 6-10 faint horizontal stripes. But, the white perch has no lines on it.
Types of perch and types of bass
Perch in America points towards the popular three types called silver, white, and yellow perch. In contrast, well-known basses are of two kinds largemouth and smallmouth. They each have distinctive qualities.
Silver perch, otherwise known as sand perch are small fishes. They weigh up to 0.5 pounds. Despite being silver perch, they are close relatives of the redfish. Anglers can usually find the perch in shallow waters. There is a trend to use the silver perch as bait for bigger fish.
White perch is highly adaptive. This fish can live in freshwater as well as saltwater. In general, white perch occupies the five Great Lakes. During the spawning season, the white perch migrates. After growing, it can weigh about 1 pound.
Yellow perch is among the list of popular fish in America. However, it may just be the only fish that is a genuine member of the perch family. This perch has a gold-like color, tiger stripes, and a pleasing appearance. Once matured, it can weigh up to 1 pound or more.
The largemouth bass is a gamefish that occupies the freshwater. However, It can survive most habitat conditions. With an average 16 year lifespan, they can grow 16” or more. The full-grown largemouth is one of the top predators in its ecosystem. Therefore, this bass prefers to live under covers.
Smallmouth bass lives in clearwater lakes. They can grow to be 14” long and weigh about 7 pounds. During spring, the males swim into the spawning area. Most females can lay 2000-15000 eggs. Fry feeds on zooplankton. As they grow, they start prying upon fish and crayfish.
Differences in taste
Bass has a fishy taste. In contrast, perch has a sweeter fresher taste, and the largemouth bass, yellow perch showcase very different culinary values.
Bass boasts a mild flavor. Therefore, this gamefish would have a raw impact if not prepared carefully. The largemouth has a watery and less clean flavor. However, the taste of bass can vary from person to person. Marinating, removing blood vessels can improve the taste. Also, a preference for the fishy flavor would make the largemouth bass taste ideal.
Yellow perch is otherwise known as the best panfish. It delivers a sweet, savory taste. The overall flavor of the perch is similar to a walleye but more refined. This species is omnivorous. Such eating habit of the fish is responsible for its quality taste. Even the pink translucent flesh does not have much of a fishy smell.
Differences in texture
Bass has a firmer texture than the perch. Perch has a smooth consistency. After cooking, the perch becomes flaky. With a few bones in the fillet, the bass has a firm texture that requires careful handling.
Differences in nutrition
Perch has a lower amount of fat than the bass. There is about 0.6g of fat in perch, which is 1% per fillet. On the other hand, the bass has about 2.9g of fat, counting up to 4% per fillet.
In each serving, the bass carries about 90 calories. Perch, in contrast, has only 54 calories preserving.
Perch has a small amount of iron per fillet which comes up to 3%. Bass has about 7% iron per fillet.
Fishing Tips
Bass fishing
Credit: Image by Ascyrafft Adnan from Pixabay
- Spinnerbait with a red hook raises the predatory instinct in the bass, inviting it to bite.
- A worn, torn plastic bait works well with bass fishing, as they like to pray upon the wounded.
- Using a sharp hook helps to control the strong-jawed bass.
- Targeting covered areas like under the docks can yield better results. The bass likes to hide.
- Bass swims with the current, so facing the wind is a good idea.
Perch fishing
Credit: Image by Kasjan Farbisz from Pixabay
- Fishing on the bottom is better. Perch feeds first on the bottom.
- A lake connected with a river system would have a better perch population.
- Clearwater is where the perch hunts. Fishing here would increase chances.
- Lightweight hook and minnow are an excellent combination for perch fishing.
- Strips of fish belly flesh work well as baits.
Conclusion
Perch and bass are broad terms. Even so, the key species of the two fishes have their own unique identities. The largemouth bass and the yellow perch are the ones that stand out the most. They are visually very different but live in similar conditions. As for the taste, texture, the yellow perch are seemingly better. Nutrition-wise, the bass is stronger than the perch.
Summing up, both bass and perch are worthy catches for the angler. Moreover, they are good food ingredients.
Sources:
https://canalrivertrust.org.uk/enjoy-the-waterways/fishing/fish-species/perch
https://www.britannica.com/animal/perch
https://www.fitbit.com/foods/Perch/81559
https://www.fitbit.com/foods/Freshwater+Bass+Raw/25945
https://www.fws.gov/fisheries/freshwater-fish-of-america/largemouth_bass.html
https://www.cuisinevault.com/white-perch-vs-white-bass
https://tpwd.texas.gov/huntwild/wild/species/lmb
https://tpwd.texas.gov/huntwild/wild/species/smb
https://www.seafoodsource.com/seafood-handbook/finfish/perch-yellow
https://luremefish.com/bass-fish-taste
https://www.advnture.com/how-to/catch-yellow-perch