Canoe Without Thwart - Fresh Water Fishin

Whether you are a seasoned canoeist or just learning the ropes, you have most likely wondered about the thwarts of a canoe and what would happen if you were to remove them.

With that in mind, we will go over the definition of a canoe without thwart, its impact on performance, advantages, and disadvantages.

Let’s take an in-depth look to understand it better,

Table of Contents

What is a Canoe Thwart?

A canoe thwart is a crosspiece between seats that provides support and stability for paddlers and connects the gunwales.

In other words, thwarts act as the connection between the starboard and the aft side. Furthermore, the central thwart is a bit more unique, and it’s often called the yoke.

Traditionally, canoe builders crafted thwarts from wooden planks. They primarily used tenon and mortise joints to place the thwarts and cordage to secure them further.

However, a modern canoe sports a wide range of construction materials for its parts. So, thwarts can also feature durable materials such as aluminum and polyethylene.

A Little about a Canoe Without Thwart

The purpose of thwarts was generally to strengthen and stabilize an ancient, brittle canoe. Yet, it’s still possible to paddle a modern canoe without its thwarts.

If you own a canoe with a flat bottom hull that is sturdy and rigid, you may remove the extra thwarts and test it out in the water.

Usually, the yoke is essential for a canoe, but you can somewhat replace the other crosspieces with strategically placed broad planks and canoe seats.

In contrast, if you are going with a traditional bark canoe or a similarly unstable watercraft, you may want to keep the thwarts in place for the sake of safety.

One of the main reasons for removing thwarts or using a canoe without them is the ease of portage. After all, during portage, reducing even a few pounds will be helpful.

Canoe Without Thwart Explained

There is much more to a canoe without thwart than just the visual differences. Here, we will analyze how it affects the craft’s rigidity, weight, stability, and overall performance.

Thwarts & Canoe Rigidity

By connecting the gunwales, thwarts help the canoe to remain in shape. This way, the canoe hull won’t bend or flex easily when facing the waves.

In addition, it offers a rigid surface, and canoeists can use it in tandem with the seat. Thus, the combination of bow, stern seats, and thwarts makes the canoe more rigid.

The gunwales will have more support from the thwarts, which will, in turn, stiffen up the side hulls. This way, even if the canoe hits rocks or obstacles, it will receive minor damage.

In contrast, a canoe without thwarts will suffer more significant damage from impacts due to its lowered rigidity and may become bent out of shape.

Canoe Weight Without Thwart

Typically a wooden thwart weighs around 2 lbs or 0.9 kg. For an efficient canoe, the builders use about three to five thwarts.

Therefore, a canoe without thwarts will weigh less. Removing all the thwarts except the yoke will make your canoe 8 lbs or 3.6 kg lighter.

For instance, the average canoe weighs around 50 lbs or 23 kg. As a result of removing the thwarts, it will weigh approximately 42 lbs or 19.4 kg.

Every single pound will count during portage. So, a lightweight thwart-less canoe may be easier to carry on land.

While it may seem like a small change, it will add up when you portage the canoe over a long distance.

Canoe Stability & Thwart

Thwarts improve the balance of your canoe by better distributing the weight and momentum. With these, your watercraft will be a bit more stable in the waves.

On the other hand, a canoe missing the thwarts will have uneven weight distribution, and the flexing gunwales will make it unstable.

However, without the thwarts, the canoeist will be able to kneel and paddle from wherever they like, and the lowered core will offer a bit more stability.

Canoe Without Thwart Performance

Performance-wise, a canoe without thwarts is lighter and will glide better in the water. Moreover, the freedom and space for paddling will make each paddle stroke easier and more potent.

Nevertheless, if you have the thwarts, they provide a backrest and a way to place your feet for a more sustained paddling session.

These thwarts will also help you place your paddle at a comfortable height, making it easier for you to pick it up and keep it safe.

Yet, you will experience a slight increase in buoyancy without the thwarts, allowing you to bring more gear.

Aside from these, the absence of thwarts will result in a canoe losing its shape, making it unable to cut through the water as smoothly as one with thwarts.

The Advantages & Disadvantages of Paddling a Canoe Without Thwart

Paddling a thwart-less canoe takes some time and practice. Although it offers some advantages to the expert canoeist, it’s disadvantageous for a beginner.

The Advantages of a Canoe Without Thwart

The benefits of paddling a canoe without thwarts are interconnected. In the hands of an expert, these advantages will become pretty significant.

Let’s take a look,

Without the thwarts, you will be able to move around quickly within your canoe.
Less weight and more space will increase the maximum carrying capacity.
Your canoe will have better buoyancy.
In case you fall, there is a reduced chance of injuring yourself by hitting the thwart.
You will have an easier time portaging.
Moreover, you will be able to get in and out of your canoe quickly and efficiently.

Aside from these, you can fine-tune your canoe to suit your needs. You can even install an outrigger to make your craft more stable in the place of the thwarts.

The disadvantage of a Canoe Without Thwart

If you are a beginner at canoeing, it will be challenging to paddle a canoe with no thwarts. As such, you may want to learn about these difficulties beforehand.

The disadvantages you will face are,

Wobbly canoe hulls will make paddling difficult.
A lack of durability.
Insufficient supports to protect the shape of your canoe.
The seat frames may crack when it faces the pressure from the starboard and aft sides.
In addition, it will take a lot of effort to balance this canoe on the water.

Therefore, you should gain experience paddling a canoe with thwarts before you try out a thwart-less canoe.

Summing Up

The world of the canoe is diverse. With so many differing opinions on the topic, it can be hard to decide whether or not a canoe without thwart is right for you.

After all, picking a suitable canoe is essential if you want to have an enjoyable canoeing experience.

Nevertheless, you can always paddle out the doubts by removing the thwarts and taking the canoe out in the water for a short trip.

Besides, if you’ve yet to paddle one yourself, you can try renting one before making your decision!

Read more about Canoe Without Keel

Source;

Share this:

Related